"The darker the shadows fall over an era, the greater the longing for the light of individuals whose bourgeois equanimity has been robbed by the shadowy nature and sacrilege of their present. The longing for light and enlightenment has led us to the only bright spot that remains for us: Christ. And that will remain for us. He is our entire background, our guide, and our goal."
~ Hans Scholl (of The White Rose anti-Nazi student protest group, Munich, 1942)
In these weeks I have taken up again the study of the group that emerged briefly in opposition to Adolf Hitler at the University of Munich in Germany during World War II, The White Rose. A more intensive look at these students opens up a unique perspective on one of the most violent, suffocating, dehumanizing social orders that has ever existed in human history: Hitler's National Socialist totalitarian Party-State. Here is a story of a group of ordinary German young people in the wider context of a whole generation that grew up under Nazi rule and experienced its systematic invasiveness of every aspect of human life. Even internal dissent was extraordinarily difficult, especially after Germany went to war in 1939. The lies of Nazi propaganda fed a misconceived national patriotism and people's genuine fears of being overrun by Stalin's Communist totalitarian system from the Soviet Union. All of this combined with the natural human desire for economic security and a comfortable life, the pressure to conform, and the fear of expressing any criticism or opposition to Hitler or his regime.
So many German people remained bound to the Nazis — whether through hollow enthusiasm or crushed silence — in a kind of psychological and spiritual paralysis of various and complex origins. There were numerous factors, including a combination of escalating terror, lingering wishful thinking about economic success and “social order,” and the desperate hope of escaping Soviet Communism through a neopagan revival of mythical Teutonic strength. It was difficult to avoid the trap of active collaboration (or at least the passive complicity of being dragged along) with Hitler’s “triumphant” war, even as it was carrying out a racist program of genocide and ethnic cleansing out of hatred for the Jews and in pursuit of a "Greater Germany" expanding into Eastern Europe and Ukraine.
The leaflet campaign of The White Rose was a brave and energetic effort to “do something,” and — even though it never stood much chance of political success — it did show Germany and the world that there was still a narrow space where the human conscience could shine. It was a witness to the transcendent human vocation for which these students were willing to give their lives. Above all, it was an experience through which they encountered Jesus Christ and grew in love for Him even in the midst of so many other activities and concerns. Ultimately the protagonists were able to embrace Christ through sharing in His death, which they faced with a serenity — even a joy — that shocked their executioners. Their joy promised something new even as their nation was falling apart all around them.
I will continue to research and learn more about Hans and Sophie Scholl, Christoph Probst (whose beautiful “conversion story” I have just written about for my monthly article series, and which will appear in April 2026), Alexander Schmorell, Willi Graf, Kurt Huber, and others in The White Rose circle who mentored and supported them in the resistance work that they took up at great risk and with considerable hesitation, but ultimately standing before God with clarity of conscience. They were real people with flaws and doubts. They were full of immature passions and youthful ideals and they argued amongst themselves. They were not fine-tuned for success, but they tried their best. And, of course, they failed. But history remembers them (even if it doesn’t understand them), because they acted out of love for the truth and genuine love for their country and the world. It was a love that grew within them and reached maturity in the face of their own deaths in 1943. Ultimately they acted for love and persevered in love to the end because they surrendered themselves to the One whose love is greater than death.
Looking at these people and these events as a citizen of the USA in the “Bloody Summer of 2025” has rekindled hope in my own heart regarding our nation even though it too seems to be falling apart all around us in these days. The United States is fundamentally different from Germany in the Nazi era and faces different dangers. I don’t believe that the current regime is “just like Hitler,” no matter how much agitation is bound up with this comparison. Nevertheless, in my opinion, this regime remains reckless, callous, disoriented, and dangerous for our nation and the world for many other reasons. However, the current regime is too often hounded by an “opposition” that is poisoned by its own compromises and delusions. The opposition denounces this regime’s failure to respect human rights, but it also participates in manufacturing and lobbying for new so-called human rights drawn forth from ideologies that aim at the very foundations of human dignity and seek to undermine the basic principles of moral law written by God in the depths of every human heart.
The United States has a whole different context of problems in 2025 than Nazi Germany 85 years ago. We may be able to learn something, however, from the history of the people of those days, from what Hans Scholl called the “bourgeois equanimity” that dominated the mentality of so many ordinary Germans and drove them to sell their intelligence and freedom for the false promises of a demagogue. Just like us, their daily lives were controlled by the desperate desire to hold on at all costs to the material comforts of their technologically advanced society. They were compelled to blind themselves to the enormous evils perpetrated for their comforts and alleged “greatness,” and then to distract themselves as their own society began to fall apart due to the “shadowy nature and sacrilege of their present.”
How well do we perceive the “shadowy nature” (not to mention the sacrilege) of our own present? The United States has long existed as a “two-party system,” with multiple levels of deeply rooted institutions that have a long history of preventing any faction from seizing total power. Externally, we are nothing like the Weimar Republic. We have different problems, and our future is subject to many forces that are beyond our control. But both political parties have become ugly and intolerable in our current society (in different ways and for different reasons). We don’t seem very competent at “voting for the lesser evil” without losing our heads and running after the distorted, polarized, and foolish propaganda of whichever party we end up choosing. How quickly we adopt its proposals, adapt ourselves to its changes of content and/or strategy, and join in demonizing members of the other party. Are we motivated by something more than our grasping to preserve and increase our unprecedented material comforts, our pride, and our lust for success — for “winning” at all costs? Is this our 2025 version of bourgeois equanimity? Whatever it is, it cannot satisfy us. It’s falling apart all around us, falling into the shadows, evaporating into the superficial self-indulgence that increasingly dominates our every day.
Why are we compelled to heap contempt on other people who pop up on our screens and seem to be repeating slogans from the opposing group? We don’t know these people, the stories of their real lives, the motivations of their conflicted hearts. Do we even try to consider them as human persons? Although we can’t see them as God sees them, can we not aspire to love them? Not that we should have soft minds, but can we open a space for them in our minds and hearts, open paths to dialogue, endure them with hope in the working of the unfathomable grace of God in their hearts? If we are convinced we must oppose someone else’s ideas or projects, can we not do so with honor, reason, and compassion? This entails not rhetorical tricks, but being present with love: the love for the human person that is vulnerable to the point of suffering. This is difficult: in fact, it’s impossible unless we ourselves have experienced this love and allow ourselves to be carried by this love and grow through this love. We must not be afraid, but rather be patient with one another and with ourselves.
Perhaps we are struggling to grow in truth and love.
Hans Scholl, as a teenager, became a leader in Hitler Youth! He carried a Nazi flag past the Fuhrer’s grandstand at the Nuremberg rally of 1935. Who would have known back then where God was leading him? It was the presence of people who loved him with patience and perseverance that led him on a journey to the truth that was not without difficulty. The light shined in the darkness of his heart and he longed for it.
What do we know about the hearts of our brothers and sisters who are encompassed in the infinitely compassionate Heart of Jesus? What do we know of the longing He awakens within them, or the inner conflicts and struggles and sufferings that they endure, the suffering that He endures with them and in them and for them? How dare we have contempt for any human person?!
It’s not surprising that violence continued to rage among us in the Summer of 2025, that shootings have taken place in homes, shopping malls, and even churches. Most recently, there has been the assassination of political and social activist Charlie Kirk. May his soul rest in peace and may God console his poor family. This was a heinous act of violence that must not be viewed a single iota “less horrible” by those who have disagreements with the substance and/or style of his expressed views. Yet there were some people who are so engulfed in the hyper-partisan rage of their own shallow faction that they “celebrated” or otherwise commented flippantly about his death. It’s a sad thing that the internet has trained people to put forth in unjust words their most cruel and most vulgar impulses. This was a terrible murder! How can we turn to anything other than the infinite goodness and love and mercy of God?
What we all really need to do is to repent from out of the depths of our own souls, acknowledging the sins (yes, sins) by which we all participate in the spiral of violence in our country. And if we face the darkness — the shadows that we invite among us so as to hide ourselves from our own shrinking hearts — if we face the darkness, we might glimpse the light of Christ who remains with us and shows His merciful love.
Jesus Christ is the meaning and purpose of our lives, of nations, of the whole universe. This is what matters, and we must hold fast to him with greater firmness in these dark days as the shadows fall on us. His light is greater and burns more brightly in the growing darkness, and His grace works to awaken us and stir up within us that “longing for light.”